Can a Spinosaurus kill a Megalodon?


Dinosaurs were built for the kill. At least the carnivorous types were. Heavily armored with razor-sharp teeth, claws, and spiked tails. There is no doubt some of these creatures were definitely apex predators. Speculation on which dinosaurs preyed on which has always been of interest to scientist and dino fans alike. One wonders, could a spinosaurus kill a megalodon?

The Spinosaurus & Megalodon lived in different periods, making the chances of them meeting seemingly impossible. However, based on what we currently know about these creatures’ biology & physiology, a Spinosaurus would have a difficult time killing a Megalodon. But the opposite may have been true had they met in water.

To better understand this scenario and the reasoning behind the projected result of a fight between these creatures, we will discuss their various biologies and physiologies. This will help us understand and better formulate an approximation of a physical engagement between these two different dinosaur species. We will also discuss their natural environments, hunting strategies, and weapons of choice.

Spinosaurus

Spinosauri were amongst the largest species of dinosaurs to roam the earth. Its size was comparable and larger than that of the Tyrannosaurus. They had large vertical neural spines that grew along their back vertebrae, for which they were named. These spines were slightly longer from the front towards the back. The function is disputed, with some scientists theorizing that it was more hump-like than sail-like. This would indicate another purpose like aquatic locomotion rather than thermoregulation. 

Spinosaurus Environment

The spinosaurus lived in North Africa in the late Cretaceous period, between 99 and 93 million years ago. Its remains or fossils were first discovered in Egypt by a German paleontologist named Ernst Stromer in 1912. Spinosauri were semi-aquatic dinosaurs that lived in humid environments, such as mangrove forests, swamps, and tidal flats. Spinosauri were amongst the largest species of dinosaurs to roam the earth at the time. Its size was comparable and larger than that of the Tyrannosaurus.

Spinosaurus Physiology

Spinosauri is estimated to be 12 to 18 meters or 41 to 59 feet in length. It could weigh approximately 7 to 23 tons or 14000 to 46000 pounds. Its skull was crocodilian in form, with conical unserrated teeth. The bite force of spinosauri is estimated to be around 19613 newtons, 2 tonnes or  4409 pounds-force.  It had large forelimbs with ended in three-fingered hand-like appendages, of which only the first finger had a long and large claw attached. It had a long narrow tail with tall spines and haemal arches that formed a paddle-like appendage that it used to swim. Its hind legs were short in proportion to its body, with the hips reduced. This suggests that the spinosaurus move close to the ground.

Spinosaurus diet

The hunting strategy of the spinosaurus was that of ambush in shallow waters. The body type indicates that although it hunted in bodies of water, it mainly preyed on shore-animals and fish in shallow waters. It used its tail, mouth, and claws in combination for hunting. The shape of this dinosaur’s skull indicates that it primarily fed and preyed on fish.

However, the spinosaurus was an opportunistic predator. This meant that it fed on any animals that might have come within reach. The reasoning behind this is due to a tooth from a spinosaurus found within the remains of a pterosaur. Below we will discuss some of the other dinosaurs that the spinosaurus preyed and fed upon, such as sharks, Mawsonia, and Iguanodon.

  • Mawsonia is a prehistoric fish species that grew in size from 3.5 meters or 11.5 feet to 6.3 meters or 20.7 feet in length. This genus of fish dinosaur is said to have been the natural prey for the spinosaurus. They lived in large water bodies, and these dinosaurs’ fossils have been found in North Africa, Brazil, and South America. They have six fins in different areas running along their body.
  • The Iguanodon was a genus of ornithopod dinosaurs that was preyed upon by other carnivorous dinosaurs like the spinosaurus. Ornithopods are dinosaurs that started as small bipedal grazers. Iquanodons were large herbivores that moved on all fours while walking and on two feet when running. They have a characteristic thumb spike which they used against predators.
  • Smaller shark species like Cretolamna and possibly younger Cretoxyrhina could have been preyed upon by spinosauri. However, Cretoxyrhina grew to be as big as 8 meters or 26 feet, and at this stage of its life span, it could compete with a spinosaurus as an apex predator. Cretalamna were smaller sharks of about 2.3 meters or 7.54 feet, making them possible prey for spinosauri.

Megalodon

Prehistoric megalodon shark

Megalodons lived around 23 to 3.6 years ago and were the apex predator of the oceans at the time. They are often mistakenly referenced as relatives of the great white sharks we encounter today.

However, these extinct species of shark belong to their own family of sharks called Otodus, which diverged from the great white shark species. They were similar in appearance to the great white sharks but with blunter and wider jaws. The fins were more robust, and the body larger and thicker in diameter.

Megalodon Environment

The megalodons lived in various oceans worldwide, from Europe, Africa, North and South America, and Australia. Most of their fossils, however, have been found in subtropical to temperate climates. They inhabited shallow coastal waters, swampy lagoons, and deepwater environments. This means that they could regulate their body temperatures to endure lower temperatures. It is estimated that megalodons could live in temperature ranges from 1-24°C or 34-75°F. 

Megalodon Physiology

Megalodons are often referred to as leviathans in myths and stories. There is a good reason for this. These sharks’ female species are estimated to have reached up to 17 meters or 56 feet in length and weighed up to 59.4 metric tons or 65.5 short tons, and could move at 18 km/h or 11mph underwater. 

The males were smaller, measuring only up to 14.3 meters or 47 feet in length, and weighing 33.9 metric tons or 37.4 short tons. Megalodon teeth could reach up to 18 centimeters or 7 inches, and the mouth of these sharks could span 2.7 by 3.4 meters or 8.8 by 11.1 feet wide. That’s the size of a small car. The bite force is estimated to be around 180000 Newtons that 18 metric tons or 40960 pounds of force.

Megalodon Diet

The megalodons’ diets ranged from whales, giant squids, dolphins, sharks, seals, and turtles. The megalodon’s hunting strategy changed depending on the size of its prey. For bigger prey like whales, the megalodons would target the whales’ hearts or lungs while swimming at great speeds.

Prey that exceeded the megalodon’s size would be immobilized through the removal of appendages such as tails, fins, and flippers. Smaller prey was eaten whole or shredded and eaten. Megalodons hunted close to shore when young and further offshore as they matured to engage larger prey such as whales.

Spinosaurus and Megalodon battle scenarios

Based on the current information we have, it is inconceivable that a spinosaurus would be able to kill a megalodon under normal circumstances. Physical engagement requirements between the two species rely heavily upon the fact that the spinosaurus would be submerged in relatively deep water.

This ensures that the favor for victory lies almost always with the megalodon.  It is also unlikely that the spinosaurus would be able to use its tail or claws to inflict any substantial damage to the megalodon while in water. Below we detail three possible scenarios.

  1. The first scenario would place a spinosaurus in its normal environment, where it would hunt on the shore or within the water itself semi or fully submerged in coastal waters close to shore. Megalodon did not hunt in water that could not envelop them fully. Fully submerged spinosauri would be prime targets for megalodons because the spinosauri would be defenseless from behind or underneath attacks. A Megalodon would not hunt semi-submerged spinosaurus as it would not be able to attack it at that depth.
  2. The only scenario where a spinosaurus would have a chance is if the megalodon had washed up onshore. If the spinosaurus could avoid the thrashing jaws and tail of the megalodon, it would be able to either kill it or out-wait it and feed on it while it was suffocating.
  3. The third scenario entails that the spinosaurus would be hunting offshore, fully submerged underwater. In this scenario, the megalodon would remove the tail, claws, and feet from the spinosaurus before devouring it. Due to the difference in bite force and speed in the water, the spinosaurus would be unable to do any real damage or defend itself.

Conclusion

Although huge, the spinosaurus’ power and speed in water cannot be compared to that of the megalodons. If the two dinosaurs met on land, the spinosaurus would obviously have the advantage. However, as both hunted in the water, the most likely outcome would have been that the megalodon would have killed the spinosaurus if these dinosaurs lived in the same period of time.

John

Johns fascination with science, nature and the world started from a young age. His curious mind led him to pursue an education in the sciences and now he loves sharing interesting info with the world.

Recent Posts